e.l.f. Pout Clout Lip Plumping Pen

Reviewer verdict

Across 12 YouTube reviews, the e.l.f. Cosmetics e.l.f. Pout Clout Lip Plumping Pen earns a Summa score of 3.6/5, ranking #2 among Lips (Lipstick, Lip Gloss, Liner). Reviewers most often praise its color payoff, texture/finish, comfort, while the most common criticisms concern other.

Reviewers praise this product for its excellent value, combining the benefits of a plumper, gloss, and balm for just $8. The formula is consistently described as comfortable, hydrating, and non-sticky, gliding on smoothly to provide a glossy shine. While marketed as sheer, many were impressed by the buildable and noticeable color payoff, especially in the darker shades. The experience is enhanced by a pleasant, mild cooling or tingling sensation that isn't painful like more intense plumpers. Users also appreciate the convenient and precise application from the click-pen design, making it a go-to for an easy, everyday juicy lip look with a good range of wearable colors.

The most significant drawback is the product's failure to deliver a noticeable plumping effect; the tingling sensation does not translate to visibly fuller lips. Its longevity is poor, as the formula transfers easily and wears off quickly with eating or drinking. The non-retractable click-pen applicator is a common complaint, as it can lead to wasted product and messy application if too much is dispensed. Furthermore, the soft formula is fragile and can break easily. Some users also found it to be slightly sticky, and deeper shades have a tendency to bleed without a lip liner.

Analysis based on 12 YouTube reviews (2h 11m of video) with 105 pros and 58 cons extracted.

Pros (105)

Cons (58)

Review sources

• Full Face Using ONLY Elf Cosmetics Products! 16 pros, 9 cons
• NEW e.l.f Liquid Lipsticks & Plumping Glosses | LIP SWATCHES / REVIEW by KathleenLights — 13 pros, 9 cons
• e.l.f Pout Clout Lip Plumping Pen Review In Toasted & Pinky Up BEFORE You Buy by Jenn Reviews — 10 pros, 8 cons
• NEW ELF POUT CLOUT LIP PLUMPING PENS! #elfcosmetics by Carmel Nicole — 10 pros, 8 cons
• ALL 8 of the new elf POUT CLOUT lip plumping pens💄🎀 review and swatches 12 pros, 4 cons
• *new $8* e.l.f. COSMETICS POUT CLOUT LIP PLUMPING PEN + NATURAL LIGHTING SWATCHES | MagdalineJanet by Magdaline Janet — 9 pros, 6 cons
• ELF POUT CLOUT LIP PLUMPING PEN REVIEW by Sarah Brady — 8 pros, 4 cons
• e.l.f. Lip Combo Review | Espresso Lip Liner + Pout Cloud + Lip Oil (Budget Beauty Win?) 6 pros, 3 cons
• Quick Reviews of Viral Makeup (Elf Pout Clout, Charlotte Tilbury, Hourglass and More!) 6 pros, 2 cons
• Trying ALL the new ELF Makeup + my other affordable faves by Jessica Braun — 6 pros, 2 cons
• New E.L.F.ing review! 5 pros, 1 cons
• FULL FACE OF AFFORDABLE MAKEUP - ELF COSMETICS NEW LAUNCHES REVIEW by Yari G — 4 pros, 2 cons

Frequently asked questions