Bakuchiol Serum

Reviewer verdict

Across 17 YouTube reviews, the Herbivore Botanicals Bakuchiol Serum earns a Summa score of 4/5, ranking #27 among Serums & Treatments. Reviewers most often praise its ingredients, skin irritation/sensitivity, long-term results, while the most common criticisms concern ingredients, value for money.

The Bakuchiol Serum is widely praised across reviewers for its bakuchiol-based, plant-derived formula and clean ingredient profile, with many (30 mentions) highlighting vegan, cruelty-free, fragrance- and alcohol-free claims and photostability. Reviewers frequently note it as a gentle retinol alternative (multiple mentions) that delivers smoothing, plumping, and anti-aging benefits over time (21 mentions) while being suitable for sensitive or pregnancy-safe routines (27 mentions praising low irritation). Many also compliment its hydrating, non-sticky texture and fast absorption (17–16 mentions) and report visible improvements in tone, texture, and radiance within days to weeks (14 mentions). Overall, reviewers commonly praise its pleasant application experience and broad suitability for dry or sensitive skin types (multiple aspect groups).

Criticisms center on ingredient transparency and formulation quality (17 mentions), including concerns about added dyes, questionable or low bakuchiol content, and unclear use of amethyst extract, with some reviewers calling out potential misleading labeling. Value-for-money and price are recurrent complaints (14 mentions), with several reviewers finding the serum pricey for the amount and not clearly worth repurchasing given results. A minority reported irritation or tingling (6 mentions) and issues with texture control, pilling, or runniness and dispenser problems (application/packaging concerns: 5–3 mentions). A few reviewers also raised longer-term safety uncertainties and environmental/sourcing concerns (listed among ingredient cons).

Analysis based on 17 YouTube reviews (3h 10m of video) with 185 pros and 59 cons extracted.

Pros (185)

Cons (59)

Review sources

• HERBIVORE BOTANICALS' CLEAN FACIAL SKINCARE - BEST FACIAL OILS, SERUMS AND MORE! by Carmine Montalto [SKINCARMA] — 38 pros, 11 cons
• herbivore moon fruit 1% bakuchiol + peptides retinol alternative serum | trial + review by alex greyson — 14 pros, 9 cons
• Trying Vegan Skincare! | Herbivore Botanicals Review + DEMO by DaGlamGoat — 22 pros, 1 cons
• Herbivore Bakuchiol Retinol Serum My 2 Weeks Review by Svetlana — 14 pros, 4 cons
• Bakuchiol by Herbivore, a retinol alternative? by J Scott Beauty — 16 pros, 2 cons
• Herbivore Moon Fruit 1% Bakuchiol + Peptides Retinol Alternative Serum (REVIEW & 7 DAY RESULTS) by Dani Smith — 13 pros, 4 cons
• NEW SKINCARE LAUNCHES & MY THOUGHTS | HERBIVORE BAKUCHIOL, YOUTH TO THE PEOPLE ADAPTOGEN MIST by Lindsey Munette — 13 pros, 0 cons
• Best RETINOL Alternatives: Peptides, Bakuchiol, Retinaldehydes | Turn Back the Clock! by Free Range Diva — 11 pros, 2 cons
• Stop Wasting Time On Bad Bakuchiol! by Cassandra Bankson — 8 pros, 5 cons
• HERBIVORE BAKUCHIOL SERUM💎📆💎One Month Later! by Lauren O’Connell — 5 pros, 7 cons
• Best Bakuchiol Serum​ 2025 | Top 10 Best Bakuchiol Serums for Every Skin Type–Retinol’s Gentle Twin! by Best Store — 11 pros, 0 cons
• Revolution Bakuchiol Serum - Review by The Beauty Maverick — 7 pros, 4 cons
• SKINCARE BRANDS THAT LIED - Exposing The Shady Dishonest Brands in Skin Care by Mad About Skin — 2 pros, 5 cons
• Retinol SIMPLIFIED by AliceintheRabbitHole — 5 pros, 1 cons
• BEST ANTI-AGING SKINCARE PRODUCTS! CAUDALIE, KIEHL'S, MURAD, LANCOME, HERBIVORE | Brett Guy Glam by Brett Harris — 6 pros, 0 cons
• Bakuchiol Skincare Favorites- Retinol Alternatives - Best Bakuchiol Serums by No BS Beauty — 0 pros, 3 cons
• My Current Skincare Routine, 3 Products, Super Simple! 2023 UPDATE by Britt Witkin — 0 pros, 1 cons

Frequently asked questions